A Analysis Comparison of Western and Non-Western Healing Arts

Alusine M. Kanu, D.A. 

Western therapeutic arts can be as opposed and contrasted with non-western therapeutic arts. This article identifies the western therapeutic art of multicultural counseling in comparison to non-western therapeutic arts. Analysis has indicated the Western ideology is embedded in the procedures of counseling and improvement (Daniels, 2007). Western counseling is oriented principally towards encouraging folks assistance by themselves so they can correctly operate by adapting to their environmental contexts. Western ideology emphasizes the rational above the relational, the rational above the emotional, opposition above cooperation, and independence above interdependence.

 Western ideology is centered on individualism, which frequently potential customers to self-focused habits. The objective of western counseling is the strengthening of the self, individuality, or moi. The philosophy powering Chinese drugs is a melding of tenets from Buddhism, Confucianism, and the combined religious and philosophical concepts of Taoism. Though there are many educational facilities of believed between practitioners of common Chinese drugs, 5 Taoist axioms kind its foundation. There are natural guidelines which govern the universe, together with human beings. The natural purchase of the universe is innately harmonious and nicely organized. When people today live according to the guidelines of the universe, they live in harmony with that universe and the natural ecosystem. The universe is dynamic, with transform as it truly is only continuous. Stagnation is in opposition to the legislation of the universe and will cause what Western drugs phone calls illness. All residing matters are linked and interdependent. People are intimately linked to and affected by all sides of their ecosystem. The broader conceptual framework on multicultural counseling competencies is centered on the Affiliation for Multicultural Counseling and Development as described in Multicultural Counseling Competencies (Roysircar et al., 2003). The product emphasizes a practitioner’s consciousness of cultural values, beliefs, and biases in purchase to be knowledgeable of the client’s globe watch and supply culturally appropriate procedure.

 J.D. Kinzie (1990), comparing basic western values with Asian values, illustrates parts of difference in between western and non-western therapeutic. It demonstrates that Indochinese affected individual values focus on interdependence, and western practitioners consider in private preference and independence. Chinese have structured and appropriate social interactions, when Westerners consider in situational ethics, problem for authorities, and equality of spouse and children interactions. Chinese therapeutic thinks 1 must live in harmony with mother nature, and Westerners consider mother nature is to be mastered. Chinese consider that psychological illness is brought about by imbalance in cosmic forces or lack of will electric power. Westerners consider that psychological illness is a consequence of psychological and actual physical components. Indochinese affected individual values are that procedure must be brief and immediate. Westerners consider treatment could get a extended time. Easterners consider the healer must be energetic and give alternatives to difficulties. Westerners see the therapist as frequently passive, and the finest option is 1 designed by the affected individual.

 Another important difference is how the affected individual is regarded. In western drugs, people with identical issues or conditions ordinarily will receive practically the exact procedure. In common Chinese drugs, the doctor treats the affected individual, and not the issue, believing that equivalent conditions can have entirely unique will cause. In conditions of the principles upon which it is centered and the solutions utilized, common Chinese drugs is regarded as by several in the west to be a radically unique procedure. At the core of western counseling treatment lie emotions: validating, uncovering, processing, accepting and expressing emotions. Whichever else is included in therapeutic, Westerners consider that being familiar with their emotions improved potential customers to bigger psychological overall health. Chinese customarily get the reverse watch: controlling one’s emotional expression is needed for psychological overall health in its place they emphasize appropriate carry out and silent reserve. So a Chinese counselee will commonly give brief responses and discuss only when questioned by the counselor. Also, Asians are far more relaxed with silence than Westerners. Westerners ordinarily see a pause of a few seconds in a conver-sation as an invitation to discuss. Asians frequently pause significantly more time in between responses.

Standard Chinese drugs is an historical and even now quite vital holistic procedure of overall health and therapeutic, centered on the idea of harmony and balance and utilizing the concepts of moderation and prevention. In theory and follow, common Chinese drugs is completely unique from western drugs, both equally in conditions of thinking of how the human human body operates and how illness occurs and must be treated. In common Chinese drugs, both equally philosophically and medically, moderation in all matters is advocated, as is residing in harmony with mother nature and striving for balance in all matters. Prevention is also a essential objective of Chinese drugs, and significantly emphasis is positioned on educating the affected individual to live responsibly.

 The important difference in between common counseling and multicultural counseling is that a basic principle of multicultural counseling emphasizes being familiar with clients from their sociocultural contexts (e.g., race, gender, class, sexual orientation, disability, age, religion, language and religion). With out thinking of sociocultural contexts, it is hard to take a look at consequences of class on the total person. Interaction designs also vary in between western and non-western cultures. Westerners like direct conversation. However, Chinese lifestyle sees this kind of com-munication as confrontational, specially to 1 in a culturally top-quality posture. Subtlety and indirect assistance is significantly prized in Asian cultures. Also, Chinese clients will almost never complain overtly that they are dissatisfied with treatment they merely will not return.

The similarity in between Chinese and Western therapeutic procedures is the developing improvement of analysis. Hou, Bai, et al. (2008) determined regular matters coated by counseling similar journals in Western cultures, together with counseling interventions outcomes, counseling outcomes, counseling interventions in affiliation with other treatment plans (e.g., treatment), moral issues, counseling strategies and applications, counseling procedures, counselor qualification and skilled improvement and surveys on the position of counseling. The improvement of indigenous counseling in Chinese communities may well involve analysis that examines the utility of adapting contexts, as nicely as finding options of assorted shopper populations, coaching and credentialing of counseling pros and interventions that incorporate indigenous procedures into procedure (Blowers, 1996). As the counseling job in China progresses and matures, it would be helpful for pros to engage in a far more energetic position in many sorts of collaboration, as they must enrich the international counseling neighborhood by means of synthesizing Eastern and Western cultural values into their analysis and follow work (Leung, 2003). Yet another therapeutic follow is that the Chinese code of ethics is greatly affected by existing moral codes in the Western globe.

 Another similarity in between Western and non-western therapeutic procedures is the realization of the prospective rewards of counseling. Constructive contacts in between East and West affect further exploration of cultures. Yet another gain is setting up have confidence in, mutual gain and appreciative marriage. Interactions by both equally cultures improve cultural competencies and understanding by encountering, difficulty solving approaches with bridging roles for transform and developing institutional help. Collaboration, for that reason, integrates Western and Eastern cultures. Assessments of overall health and therapeutic procedures are deserving of thing to consider in examining and comparing Western and non-western procedures. The scientific technique is a approach of validating therapeutic solutions and is an powerful method of procedure intervention. It follows that some non-western therapeutic solutions need to be validated by stringent analysis right before they can be reliably built-in into common Western follow. The software of the scientific technique to analyze existing or finest proof is a useful follow to evaluate by a systematic approach. The essential approach of proof centered on analysis rests on the reliability of the approach of analysis methodology, structure and information analysis. Elementary analysis demonstrates efficiency on the realistic and contextual integration of follow.

 M. Javier (2007) endorses finest procedures in intercultural overall health treatment wants to fulfill conditions which involve owning a optimistic effects on the folks and populace served, sustainable, staying responsive and suitable to affected individual and neighborhood overall health wants to cultural and environmental realities, staying shopper-focused, strengthening obtain, coor-dinating and integrating products and services, staying successful and versatile, demonstrating management and staying progressive, displaying prospective for replication, identifying overall health and coverage wants and owning a capability for analysis. There is a excellent require to realize and embrace the unique sorts of counseling all around the globe. Analyzing the cultural values and procedures of individuals in assorted nations can lead not only to a improved being familiar with of this kind of nations, but also a richer perspective about one’s very own lifestyle and many approaches to counseling. There is a excellent offer of prospective for multicultural and cross-nationwide movements in counseling to enrich 1 one more. A concerted collaboration can enrich the sophistication of counseling analysis globe wide, develop the complexities of existing understanding and theoretical designs, improve the vary of counseling interventions, and in essence, enrich counseling efficiency across a vary of populations in Western and Eastern therapeutic procedures and outside of.


 Blowers, G. H. (1996). “The potential clients for a Chinese psychology in M. H. Bond (ed.), Handbook of Chinese Psychology (pp. one-14). Hong Kong, SAR, China: Oxford College Press.

 Daniels, J. (2007). “The Fourth Drive in Counseling and Therapy: Multicultural and Feminist Perspectives,” in Ivey et al. Theories of Counseling and Psychotherapy: A Multicultural Standpoint, (sixth ed.), pp. 319-358. Boston: Pearson Schooling.

 Hou, Z. J., Bai (2008). A ten-yr material analysis of content articles on counseling and psychotherapy revealed in the Chinese Mental Wellness Journal. Peoples Republic of China: Beijing Usual College.

 Javier, M. et al. (2007). “Greatest procedures in intercultural overall health,” Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine. three: p. 31.

 Kinzie, J. D. (1990). “Overview of scientific issues in the procedure of Southeast Asian Refugees,” in T. C. Owan (ed.) Southeast Asian Mental Wellness Treatment, Prevention Services, Training and Analysis, Washington DC: Nationwide Institute of Mental Wellness, n.d.: p. 311.

 Leung, S.A. (2003). “The journal worthy of touring: Globalization of counseling psychology,” The Counseling Psychologist, 31, pp. 412-419.

 Roysircar et al (2003). Multicultural Counseling Competencies. Alexandria VA: Affiliation of Multicultural Counseling and Development.

Source by Dr Alusine Melvin Moseray Kanu